Q&A with Carlo Bastasin
Italy’s right-wing prime minister, Giorgia Meloni, will reach four years in office next week; her government became the longest-serving in the country’s postwar history last month. We asked CUSE Nonresident Senior Fellow Carlo Bastasin about Meloni’s government and Italian politics.
How do you evaluate Prime Minister Meloni’s political achievements as well as her record in office?
The stability of Meloni’s tenure is a function of both her political ability to keep afloat in turbulent times and the opposition’s failures. And despite the fact that she has opposed a number of important EU policies (e.g., on climate or rule of law), she has managed to preserve good relations with most of her European partners.
However, of the three major reforms Meloni announced upon taking office in October 2022 to modernize Italy’s institutions, very little has been implemented. The first, judicial reform, was derailed by a failed referendum. The second, on regional autonomy, was just reintroduced as a bill on October 13, but it is still pending. The third, which was supposed to reshape the institutional framework toward a premiership, has been watered down into a new electoral law which passed last week but will face constitutional scrutiny in the coming months.
Nor has the government implemented any meaningful economic reforms. At a time of technological upheaval, the government has instead chosen to protect incumbent lobbies. Likewise, it has missed the opportunity granted by substantial EU support to mend Italy’s fragile public finances. Nevertheless, buoyed by EU funds and domestic stability, the Italian economy is registering higher growth.
Meloni’s electoral reform is designed to give election winners a more comfortable governing majority. How do her prospects look heading toward elections in 2027, and will the reform help her?
The new electoral law awards bonus parliamentary seats to the winning election alliance, provided that it wins at least 42% of the seats. It also requires parties to agree on a prime ministerial candidate and political platform before the election—an attempt, say its supporters, to eliminate the post-election bargaining processes that in the past produced unstable multiparty coalitions. However, it also makes it highly unlikely that a unifying nonpartisan figure—like the distinguished economists Carlo Ciampi, Mario Monti, or Mario Draghi in the past—could be called upon to lead a “national unity” government of the kind that have repeatedly helped Italy avert financial collapse in recent decades.
Meloni’s prospects in 2027 are directly linked to the new law. As a leader of a post-fascist party, who relies on strongly adversarial rhetoric, Meloni remains a divisive figure in Italian politics. She would have little to gain from a nonpartisan government, which would effectively marginalize her to the opposition. Next year’s election outcome remains uncertain, particularly with an extreme-right new contender, Roberto Vannacci, gaining support, so Meloni’s only option to remain in power is to obtain the strong majority bonus required by the new law.
Meloni and U.S. President Donald Trump had a very public falling out over Trump’s criticism of Pope Leo XIV, after the pontiff criticized the U.S.-Israeli war against Iran. What does this rupture tell us about the relationship between the European right and the Trump administration?
European right-wing or sovereigntist parties have a strong sense of national identitarian character derived from a conception of the state as a historical construct imbued with unique traditions and culture. President Trump’s adversarial tone toward Europe is seen by Europeans as diminishing their identity. Trump’s criticism of the pope, for instance, irritated many European citizens—and it may have contributed to the huge success of Leo's trip to France, a country with a strong secular tradition. In fact, a possible unintended consequence of Trump’s hostility toward Europe might be that European conservative or radical right-wing parties might base their chauvinism on Europe, rather than on their nation-state alone.